Cold Caney crappie — Tips to catch Caney Lake’s slabs

Jackson Parish’s ‘other fish’ are gaining more attention, as Caney Lake grass beds return and foster hordes of big black crappie. And this angler tells you how to catch your share.

From his fancy Ranger fishing rig to a nice collection of fishing gear, Jeff Glover was all decked out and ready to go for largemouth bass.

That’s what you’d expect from an angler who has a camp on Caney Lake, which is widely recognized for its lunker bass — including the long-standing state record.

But Glover’s bass fishing has often been hampered by a distraction on the lake.

It’s Jackson Parish’s “other” fish — crappie. Lots of crappie.

And this 5,000-acre lake is producing more and more slabs, although they don’t get the attention bass do.

‘I’ve always been a bass fisherman first, but these crappie sure do get your attention,” the West Monroe resident said. “I’ve been blessed to have a group of good, Godly men take time to teach me how to catch these crappie, and what I’ve found is that this is a great crappie-fishing lake.”

And his favorite time to go after crappie is right now.

“The end of January and through the month of February, that’s the best time to fish for crappie here,” Glover said. “I love fishing in the colder months because I prefer fishing deep structure. Caney has plenty of that; there are deep points, old humps and several creek channels.

“But if you want numbers, you have to fish the old main channel. Water there is 25 to 35 feet deep, with some water out in front of the spillway at 40 feet deep.”

Normally, fish suspend from 18 to 25 feet deep, but sometimes they almost hug the bottom of the lake.

This time of year, Glover said, crappie fishing follows a natural migration.

“When the water temp hits 50 degrees or below, the schools of threadfin shad in the lake migrate down the channel in bunches,” he explained. “The crappie also follow in bunches. Then the fishermen follow in bunches.

Crappie fishermen stay on the fish by keeping their eyes on the fish finder.

“On a good day down here in front of the spillway in late January or February, you can almost walk from boat to boat to boat there are so many people in some areas.”

He said the action just naturally centers around the channel.

“That river channel is like the interstate highway for the crappie in Caney,” Glover said. “That’s where they travel in the cold weather months.

“You can catch some on the secondary creeks and other deep spots, but the big numbers come from the main channel and spillway areas.”

The angler said a lot of the world’s problems — from coaching changes to politics to stock market issues — get solved during those days, as fishermen gather up and wait on the crappie bite to turn on.

And, while bass fishermen are usually more secretive and less talkative while fishing, crappie fishermen will talk about anything.

“Except exactly what they are catching them on,” Glover said.

But he doesn’t mind sharing that info. His go-to baits are Bobby Garland double silver rainbow and blue thunder plastic jigs on 1/16-ounche jigheads.

And he never puts a bait in the water without tipping it with a Crappie Nibble, usually in chartreuse color.

“You can’t go wrong with those, especially on a sunny day in the winter,” Glover said. “And if those aren’t working, the black-and-chartreuse usually will.”

Minnows are also a good bait on Caney, but Glover stays away from them unless he has to use them.

The main reason?

“I don’t like sticking my hands in and out of that minnow bucket when it’s that cold,” he said.

When his electronics show fish are moving closer to the bottom or the jig bite is off a bit, however, he will use minnows.

His favorite way to do that is by setting up a drop-shot rig, with the shiner hook about 2 feet from the weight. He lowers it to the bottom, which means that bait is swimming just above the fish.

That works best in open water, but if crappie get in the middle of the brush, he’ll still go with that rig — but he keeps some harder Crappie Nibbles on hand and puts one right on the point of the hook.

Populations of good-eating size Caney crappie are on the rise.

That makes the rig less likely to get hung up, and he can still get the point of the hook into the fish.

Spider-rigging is popular on Caney and works well, but Jeff likes to just use a couple of jig poles and feel the “thump” when he gets a bite.

That’s also the only way you can catch fish consistently when they are tight around or in structure. Besides the creek channel itself, crappie also will relate to brush tops and humps.

That’s why having good electronics and knowing how to use them is critical.

Caney isn’t a cinch to supply you with a great catch of crappie every day, though. The lake is totally open, and wind can blow you off the fish. Also, sometimes crappie get a lot of pressure, which can slow down the bite.

And, Caney crappie don’t respond well to big cold fronts blowing through, either. Sometimes it seems to bunch up the fish even more than usual, but it also can turn the bite off for a day or two.

And then there’s water clarity.

If you haven’t fished Caney, you need to know this right up front: Caney is probably the clearest lake in Louisiana.

Glover said he couldn’t believe it when he first saw the water clarity.

That means using light line and staying right on top of the fish — and sticking with clearer-water colors, for the most part.

And if the weather turns unseasonably warm earlier than usual this time of year, Caney’s crappie will start to head out of the old channel and up into the creeks.

When the temperatures get right to begin moving fish for the spawn, crappie relate to grass beds in 8 to 10 feet of water.

Those grass beds are also a reason Caney’s crappie are on the comeback: Electronics won’t help you find them here.

So you’ll just have to get in there and locate them with your favorite lure.

“Years ago, they put carp in here, and they ate all the grass,” Glover said. “Property owners were worried about grass taking over the lake, but when it was gone, it really messed up the fishing.

“But it’s coming back now. The grass beds have not only given us another way to catch good fish, but they have allowed much better spawns and crappie numbers are way up on the lake — including the big ones.”

That was proved when at least one 3-pounder was caught last spring. Jeff suspects more slabs to ring in the New Year.

If conditions continue to improve, it could signal a return to those early days of the lake when crappie were more than just Jackson Parish’s “other fish.”

And it might also mean fishermen like Glover keep that crappie gear in the boat just a little more often.

Glover’s go-to crappie gear

Marker buoys: You’re going to need a couple of those to take full advantage of Caney Lake’s deepwater crappie.

“I find it very useful to have a couple of marker buoys to throw out when you find a really good group of crappie,” Jeff Glover said. “I’ll try to locate fish on my fish finder, mark them with a way point and then fish them.

“If I catch a couple, I’ll throw out a marker buoy so it’s easier to get right back on the fish.”

Some of Glover’s other favorite go-to gear for Caney crappie include Bobby Garland plastic lures in double silver rainbow, blue thunder and black-and-chartreuse colors.

He also relies on Crappie Bites, his touch-screen Lowrance fish finder and InvizX 6-pound flourocarbon line.

He ties a 6- to 8-foot leader of that line to heavier braid line on his reels.

His favorite reels are Shimano 2500 series Sahara spinning reels, and he uses several different lengths and brands of graphite crappie rods.

“Crappie fishermen are a lot more scientific in their approach and a lot more complex with their equipment than they used to be,” Glover said. “It’s like a biology experiment out there.”

Getting the word out about Caney Lake’s crappie fishing

Benson Bagwell doesn’t have much time for crappie fishing. But he is right in the middle of the action.

As the owner of Hooks Marina at the Caney Lake spillway, Bagwell checks in with crappie fishermen this time of year on a daily basis.

“I do know that crappie fishing is making a comeback on this lake, and we are trying to get the word out about that,” Bagwell said.

He isn’t alone. As a new member of Lake Commission who oversees the lake, he is excited to see the commission and the community work to make the lake even better.

Current plans include raising money to build an ADA-approved handicap ramp on the east side of the lake.

Lake leaders are also working with the Louisiana Department of Wildlife and Fisheries to implement an improved fish structure program beginning this spring.

“For years, Caney was a trophy lake for bass and crappie,” Bagwell said. “It’s our goal to bring that back.”

A Caney crappie primer

Caney Lake is located midway between Jonesboro and Chatham. The north end of the lake is accessible on Highway 4 between the two towns, and the spillway end of the lake is accessible on Highway 34 south of Chatham.

The Jimmie Davis State Park is located on a large peninsula midway on the lake’s east side. It has two boat launches, a fishing pier, 80 picnic sites with tables and charcoal grills, pavilions, a camping site, and cabins and lodges.

Hooks Marina is located at the spillway on the east side, and it features a large ramp and concrete parking area.

Brown’s Landing, which was destroyed by fire last year, has reopened on the lake’s north end.

Both Brown’s and Hooks are full-service marinas.

Caney Lake is black crappie haven

Unlike many North Louisiana reservoirs, black crappie seem to thrive in Caney Lake’s deep, clear water.

The average depth of the lake is 16 feet.

In fact, back in the good old days, the reservoir laid claim to the state-record black crappie, which tipped the scales at 3.55 pounds.

That huge fish was caught by Chet Tidwel in February 2003.

During that time, five of the Top 10 black crappie in the state came from Caney.

Subscribe now, get unlimited access for $19.99 per year

Become the most informed Sportsman you know, with a membership to the Louisiana Sportsman Magazine and LouisianaSportsman.com.

About Kinny Haddox 518 Articles
Kinny Haddox has been writing magazine and newspaper articles about the outdoors in Louisiana for 45 years. He publishes a daily website, lakedarbonnelife.com and is a member of the Louisiana Chapter of the Outdoor Legends Hall of Fame. He and his wife, DiAnne, live in West Monroe.