is this a joke? you won't get any one to respond cause this is a waste of time, if you think an internet forum will change your deer season you are insane, if you think you will get people to agree to a shortened season, you are even more insane, and lastly if you think killing a bunch of does will improve your deer(buck) quality, then my friend you need to be committed
you asked for an opinion, there is mine, i bet i get more people to agree with my idea than yours hahahaha
What is the majority of hunters in area 2 ? Is the majority trophy hunters or just meat hunters ? I mean because if the majority of hunters in area 2 were trophy hunters then it should be 150 inch or better and just keep the dates the same . Or whatever club your in , make it a rule just in your club .
My thoughts it to leave it alone and gather data on how changing to 3 bucks/3does has affected the herds.
Beyond that, Area 2 is the biggest area. The terrain ranges from straight piney hills to the Red River bottoms. The area is too complex to make one swiping change like shortening the buck season to 30 days because the next question is which 30 days? Do you accomodate the Nov. rutting parishes? or the Dec. rutting parishes?
If you are seeking to make adjustments to increase the population of older deer, then I would suggest researching how the previous changes were made (i.e. - tags, 3 bucks/3 does, etc.) to make a game plan.
I think antler restrictions would be easier to pass than shortening the season. Forcing someone to count points only affects his decision making but taking days away removes a right.
Personally, I like the long season. I live in Lincoln Parish and enjoy hunting Nov. and Dec. rutting deer in the same parish. We eat a lot of deer meat so I like maximizing my opportunities.
I do realize the the states with the best herd structures have the most restrictionss, shortest seasons, etc. but I'm willing to kill a wallhanger locally every few years as opposed to annually to keep more days in the field. Right now, I am a little hung-over on Feb. 1st wishing I had more time to hunt.
Come on guys tell me what you think.