Louisiana Sportsman
Current Issue
CCAguns Profile Photo
Inshore Fishing in Lake Borgne / Chef Menteur

Best Light SW Spinning Reel

Wanted to get some opinions on what folks think is the best light saltwater spinning reel - mainly for specs & reds. I know the Shimano Stradic is a fine reel, as I've fished with one for years. Kind of a flimsy drag, though-burned one up on the third bull red caught that day. Don't want to spend the bucks for a Stella-that price is ridiculous.

Have been pleased with the Fin-Nor megalite, but it's hard to get parts for them. Fin-Nor's Ahab 8 would be great, but I think it's too heavy. Haven't used a Van Staal. Daiwa's always made a great spinning reel, but I've lost track of the models. Would rather BUY AMERICAN! What do ya'll think???
August 09, 2012 at 10:16pm
21 Comments
I love fishy fingers Profile Photo
Posted August 10, 2012 at 1:43am
great reel

PENN 360, I've had my 3 for three years with no problems after fishing them with deadly dudley. They are easy to repair and I have caught countless big fish on them.

• View Reports by I love fishy fingers
wdietz Profile Photo
Posted August 10, 2012 at 6:54am
American made??

Do we still make reels in USA??? If we do, I'd like to buy one myself to remind me of times gone by. I wish I had an answer for your question, but I use bait casting. Good Luck!!

• View Reports by wdietz
jls Profile Photo
jls
Posted August 10, 2012 at 8:01am
Spin Cast

$150-$200 alot $$$ to burn one u!How big Bull Red we talkin Bout, My brother uses Penn 360, I've never caught one over 30' so I've never had one burn up, Mine are Shakespear Special xcept for one Daiwa i have No use to use ABU Garcia 5500-6000 But the older models don't hold up to the Saltwater

• View Reports by jls
Lordbud7 Profile Photo
Posted August 10, 2012 at 8:06am
Stradic

You burnt up a Stradic 2500s drag?? Call Shimano and see if they will repair it for you. I've used my Stradic 2500s for everything from reds, and specks to the occasional Jack and haven't had a problem with drag.

• View Reports by Lordbud7
CCAguns Profile Photo
Posted August 10, 2012 at 8:31am
Best Light SW Spinning Reel

Lordbud,

What model Stradic 2500 do you have? The reds caught weighed 35 - 40 pounds each. While working the third one, he ran hard the second time and my Stradics drag gave way. Spool started spinning like hell. Was dunking my hand in the water and 'hand-dragging' the spool. Landed him, but the drag was shot. Maybe the newer Stradics have a better drag? I'm partial to aluminum as I've found graphite bodies catch hell in the hot sun. Had both Shimanos and Penns warp.

• View Reports by CCAguns
Capt. Ron S Profile Photo
Posted August 10, 2012 at 8:48am
shimano/okuma

About 3 years ago i purchased a shimano stradic 2500 and an okuma inspira 30 at about the same time. I put both on 7ft med. heavy castaway rods. I have used them both equally and to be honest they both work equally just as goodas the day i got them. The only real differrence was price, the okuma was about $100 less than the shimano. As far as bait casters id go with shimano all the way but not spinning tackle.

• View Reports by Capt. Ron S
dbreezy Profile Photo
Posted August 10, 2012 at 9:04am
Spinning Reel

Penn Battle 2000. Great light weight reel specifically for salt water.

• View Reports by dbreezy
wdietz Profile Photo
Posted August 10, 2012 at 10:19am
American Made!!!

The American Made or made in the USA has peaked my interest. I found only one reel that claims to be 100% made in the USA. Ardent reels, does anyone know anything about these??? Looks like the only have one model in the spinning reel catagory. I have attached a pic.

• View Reports by wdietz
wdietz Profile Photo
Posted August 10, 2012 at 10:23am
sorry

Sorry, but I couldn't attach the picture but you can go to their website at ardentreels.com.

• View Reports by wdietz
Lordbud7 Profile Photo
Posted August 10, 2012 at 9:04pm
A bunch

I've had MGFA and FH models that were stolen some years ago. Now I have FI and FJ models. Shimano will repair their reels for $25 ifout of warranty. If you call and talk to them most of the time they will waive the $25 fee and just charge you shipping. They stand behind their products!

• View Reports by Lordbud7
keakar Profile Photo
Posted August 11, 2012 at 12:40pm
my 2 cents

a few points i have learned over the years is just about some general points, nothing brand specific.

look for a reel with the drag on the front not the back end because ones in the back get banged up too much and can break or be knocked out of the setting you want.

look for thicker necks on the reel, it doesnt sound like much but the accidental being stepped on or dropped i have seen some of the more sleek looking reel break there.

look for ease of maint, i would watch for the screws, the locations and how they are made. you have to assume you will take it apart at least a few times for cleaning and regreasing so you dont want screws with shallow grooves that will be hard to remove or strip out, i look for screws with well defined grooves.

last point is look for how the anti reverse catch is located and how its made, if it breaks it can be a real PITA to use the reel without it and sometimes those things arent fixable

• View Reports by keakar
Samarai Profile Photo
Posted August 11, 2012 at 1:02pm
Reel

I have a couple of stradics and had 2 inspires which were great for 2 years but just broke apart after that. My stradics are like 8-9 years old and still strong. I replaced all my okumas and Penn with shimanos. Amazon has the Sahara for like47 dollars which is a great price for the reel.

• View Reports by Samarai
bluemoons Profile Photo
Posted August 11, 2012 at 1:12pm
spin fishing

I don't spin fish often enough to warrant buying a new reel, but if I had to buy one right now I'd get the Stradic Ci4. That thing is serious.

If you're not set on spin fishing check out the Chronarch. Same thing as the older Curados, but they upgraded the bearings and the spool. I love them.

• View Reports by bluemoons
Lordbud7 Profile Photo
Posted August 11, 2012 at 8:16pm
CI4

I had a CI4 and sold it to my neighbor. I was going to replace the handle (I don't like the round handle) on it but the more I used it the more I didn't care for the carbon fiber. It is lighter but it just feels flimsy to me. I prefer metal to CF.

• View Reports by Lordbud7
jls Profile Photo
jls
Posted August 11, 2012 at 9:50pm
Bayou Blue Red taken on Daiwa Spin Cast from Walmart

Pey

Bayou Blue Red taken on Daiwa Spin Cast from Walmart

Rod&Reel Combo

I have 4 Shakespears 3 Spincast 1 Bait cast that i just Bought so for the Bait cast has sold me, I'n caught 4-5 Nice Bass on it since i have it Can't wait to catch Big Red on it, For my $$$$ the $25-$40 combo Shakespears from Walmart service a Good Purpose the Secret is Drag setting that everything right there in Nut Shell

• View Reports by jls
CCAguns Profile Photo
Posted August 13, 2012 at 9:28am
Best Light SW Spinning Reel

Thanks, I'll check out Ardent! As far as light casting reels go, I've found the Abu Garcia Revo Premiere to perform wonderfully. It's smoother than the Shimano Chronarch IMHO, but time will tell how well it lasts. It casts a mile!

I know the carbon reels are less corrosion sensitive, but they seem flimsy and I've heard they break in the neck. I've never had that happen on an aluminum-bodied reel.

I just prefer spinning reels for SW as casting accuracy is rarely needed and wind typically plays a factor. I love my casting reels, but they struggle against the wind and they have trouble with light lines. It's just a damn shame that here in the USA we can't manufacture the finest spinning reel in the world. It shouldn't be that difficult! With all the sportsmen in this country, why are we sending our money to Japan and China???

• View Reports by CCAguns
Capt Elton, CATCHDAT Profile Photo
Posted August 13, 2012 at 10:43am
US Reel

OK, here I go, gonna get bashed for selling but, I can't stand it!!

I have always used Shimano and still love them! I have been using the US Reel 240SX sense we found out about them about 2 years ago. The best thing about them is the smooth drag, caught many Bull Reds and way too many huge Gaff Tops. Never had a single problem and never even had them apart for cleaning and lube. We use Fins Braid on them and all our reels, the only thing we learned when using braid on spinning reels is it's better to manually close the bail instead of just turning the crank.

For a $60 reel you would be impressed! OH, they are called US Reel, designed in the US but, not made here.
http://www.usreel.com/Home.aspx

http://store.catchdat.com/reels/us-reel-spinning.html

Capt E
CATCHDAT.com

• View Reports by Capt Elton, CATCHDAT
jls Profile Photo
jls
Posted August 13, 2012 at 12:55pm
Elton

^5 Capt Elton welcome back so that braided work on spin cast?

• View Reports by jls
Ameyer6 Profile Photo
Posted August 15, 2012 at 6:17am
Reel

I mainly fish Stradics, but on a whim I picked up a Pfleuger Patriarch last summer and I love it. As far as lightweight, I don't think you can find one lighter. It's made of carbon fiber and titanium. The drag seems to hold up very well also. Weight on the reel is around 6 oz I think.

• View Reports by Ameyer6
Stretch-n-out charters Profile Photo
Posted August 15, 2012 at 11:46am
reels

I use all okuma 30 on my boat and never had any problems with them and for 39 dollars you realy cant go wrong . I had a cpl i took out a cpl weekends ago pull bulls in all day and never had a lick of trouble with them

• View Reports by Stretch-n-out charters
redneckspeckchaser Profile Photo
Posted August 15, 2012 at 5:37pm
economical alternative

Berkley lightning rod shock 7ft med. with a pflugar president 6940 total price 120$ I have used one for 3 years no maintenance other than a freshwater bath after each use!

• View Reports by redneckspeckchaser

New User? Register
Password? Forgot
Inactive? Activate


Reports / Forum
PAC bank slam number 6ish?  This report contains photos  
May 13 at 1:52 pm | 3641 Views | 33 Comments
Breton Sound Bullred Fishkill.  This report contains photos   This report contains a video
May 17 at 12:12 pm | 3199 Views | 14 Comments
First noodling trip of the year  This report contains photos  
May 14 at 10:20 am | 2522 Views | 1 Comments
Father-Daughter team none stop action out of Shell Beach.  This report contains photos  
May 15 at 10:03 pm | 2202 Views | 2 Comments
Trestles 5/15/13  This report contains photos  
May 16 at 8:32 pm | 2075 Views | 7 Comments
Sick Trout Action! 5-14-13  This report contains photos  
May 14 at 10:10 pm | 1633 Views | 1 Comments
Geauxpass Scam  This report contains photos  
May 13 at 7:48 pm | 1601 Views | 9 Comments
PAC monster slam!!!!  This report contains photos  
May 17 at 2:06 pm | 1406 Views | 6 Comments
Easy Breezy in May  This report contains photos   This report contains a video
May 13 at 9:02 pm | 1401 Views | 0 Comments
Best Area to Learn for Beginner 
May 16 at 2:02 pm | 1387 Views | 20 Comments
Capt. Bob's Leeville Report  This report contains photos  
May 13 at 6:48 pm | 1317 Views | 1 Comments
Trestle Report 
May 16 at 12:58 am | 1313 Views | 2 Comments
Aj'S Thick around rig  This report contains photos  
May 14 at 7:59 am | 1229 Views | 0 Comments
Tuna time!  This report contains photos  
May 16 at 3:18 pm | 1210 Views | 3 Comments
lake Pontchartrain 
May 15 at 10:34 pm | 1158 Views | 8 Comments
What's the spillway looking like? 
May 15 at 7:47 pm | 1141 Views | 6 Comments
Venice vs Grand Isle  This report contains photos  
May 17 at 11:37 am | 1099 Views | 3 Comments
New Boat - Ready to Fish!  This report contains photos  
May 17 at 9:26 am | 923 Views | 4 Comments
SPECK-tacular!!! 5-15-13  This report contains photos  
May 15 at 5:22 pm | 894 Views | 0 Comments
REEL LIFE FISHING  This report contains photos  
May 15 at 8:34 am | 796 Views | 0 Comments
Post | Reports | Forum
PAC bank slam number 6ish?  This report contains photos  
May 13 at 1:52 pm | 3641 Views | 33 Comments
Best Area to Learn for Beginner 
May 16 at 2:02 pm | 1387 Views | 20 Comments
Breton Sound Bullred Fishkill.  This report contains photos   This report contains a video
May 17 at 12:12 pm | 3199 Views | 14 Comments
Geauxpass Scam  This report contains photos  
May 13 at 7:48 pm | 1601 Views | 9 Comments
Need tips on best kayak spots 
May 14 at 11:12 pm | 655 Views | 9 Comments
Pete's Landing 
May 15 at 7:51 am | 476 Views | 8 Comments
lake Pontchartrain 
May 15 at 10:34 pm | 1158 Views | 8 Comments
How to get my burn permit? 
May 16 at 10:04 pm | 239 Views | 8 Comments
Ski fish  This report contains photos  
May 17 at 11:47 am | 795 Views | 8 Comments
CCA REEF 
May 16 at 9:51 am | 342 Views | 7 Comments
Trestles 5/15/13  This report contains photos  
May 16 at 8:32 pm | 2075 Views | 7 Comments
Post removed???? 
5 hours ago | 121 Views | 7 Comments
New to Louisiana 
May 13 at 8:07 pm | 384 Views | 6 Comments
What's the spillway looking like? 
May 15 at 7:47 pm | 1141 Views | 6 Comments
PAC monster slam!!!!  This report contains photos  
May 17 at 2:06 pm | 1406 Views | 6 Comments
Sorrel 5/18 
Yesterday at 5:16 pm | 292 Views | 5 Comments
2 stroke or 4 
May 15 at 2:07 pm | 318 Views | 4 Comments
Hopedale 
May 15 at 9:23 am | 486 Views | 4 Comments
'She Met Her Waterloo' 
May 15 at 11:06 am | 273 Views | 4 Comments
slower day  This report contains photos  
May 15 at 1:37 pm | 419 Views | 4 Comments
Post | Reports | Forum
94 TROUT,7 REDS,1 DRUM,05-19-13  This report contains photos  
4 hours ago | 102 Views | 0 Comments
Post removed???? 
5 hours ago | 121 Views | 7 Comments
Special trouts  This report contains photos  
5 hours ago | 159 Views | 0 Comments
box stands  This report contains photos  
5 hours ago | 86 Views | 1 Comments
pigon 
5 hours ago | 63 Views | 0 Comments
Trout  This report contains photos  
6 hours ago | 164 Views | 0 Comments
Rough Day but Not too Bad  This report contains photos  
6 hours ago | 264 Views | 2 Comments
05/18 Trip  This report contains photos  
6 hours ago | 73 Views | 0 Comments
05/17 Trip  This report contains photos  
6 hours ago | 46 Views | 0 Comments
05/16 Trip  This report contains photos  
6 hours ago | 39 Views | 0 Comments
Baits ? 
7 hours ago | 128 Views | 2 Comments
Fishing rockefeller 
8 hours ago | 44 Views | 0 Comments
reel dat lures 
8 hours ago | 59 Views | 0 Comments
Windy day Trout 5-19-13  This report contains photos  
8 hours ago | 318 Views | 0 Comments
JLS report? 
8 hours ago | 220 Views | 4 Comments
Causeway Launch 
9 hours ago | 113 Views | 4 Comments
Grill Fish Taco Salad  This report contains photos  
10 hours ago | 82 Views | 0 Comments
NEW SOUTH SHORE BOAT LUNCH / MARINA 
11 hours ago | 103 Views | 0 Comments
Deer Park Cats  This report contains photos  
11 hours ago | 149 Views | 0 Comments
Kayak Fishing HWY 11 Bridge  This report contains photos  
12 hours ago | 156 Views | 0 Comments
Post | Reports | Forum





featured merchant

American Used Boats Inc.
American Used Boats Inc. American Used Boats Inc. is a used boat dealer/broker based out of Sarasota, FL with several territories throughout the state which sells boats all over the word. AUB is now going nation wide looking for Territory Managers across the United States to mana