Louisiana Sportsman
Current Issue
Andy-Man Profile Photo
Boats in Southeast Louisiana

50 HP Mercury too strong?

I have a 16'x48' custom welded flat bottom, square bow, boat from Custom Flats in Violet, St. Bernard. My 25 HP Yamaha 2-stroke, tiller is not strong enough to push the boat with 2 guys, 3 coolers for fish, drink/food, and life bait, extra battery and trolling motor, and gear. Could get a used 50 HP Mercury 2-stroke, tiller motor. Is this too strong a motor for the boat?
June 30, 2012 at 3:56pm
6 Comments
Admiral Rabbit Profile Photo
Posted June 30, 2012 at 4:37pm
'Sleep'n With 'da Fishies'

...'ya right on the 'Half Dozen Roses Margin'...if you went w/the 50 many would suggest the control console...a 50 'tiller' can get 'out of hand' real quick if you hit anything!!!(also check the Coast Guard tag)... cheers

P/S...and 'da Monks keep hammer'n away !!!

• View Reports by Admiral Rabbit
wdietz Profile Photo
Posted June 30, 2012 at 4:45pm
Too strong

I've seen people put a 115hp on custom boats that size. As far as your 25hp on that boat, you're just pissin in the wind. Anyway, your 50 Merc should be fine.

• View Reports by wdietz
bigjim Profile Photo
Posted June 30, 2012 at 9:02pm
Horsepower

Your hull is perfect for a 50, it could even handle up to a 70 reasonably.

• View Reports by bigjim
Fastcat351 Profile Photo
Posted July 01, 2012 at 9:58am
NO Problem

The hull can easily handle the 50 hp outboard. I had a 60 hp Johnson on the same hull for over 20 years. I just put a new 70 hp Yamaha on the same boat several weeks ago. Check the Repower post I made under the BOATS forum. Sounds like you have the same boat I have with the exception that my rig has a side console and some bass swivel seats mounted. Based on what you are hauling the 50 hp will be a great improvement.

• View Reports by Fastcat351
Admiral Rabbit Profile Photo
Posted July 01, 2012 at 1:35pm
' Fun Under'da Water'

...everything each said was correct...seems some don't see the safety of wheel vs tiller w/anything over 35 HP...'ya guys made me re-read my post three times ???...stiil check the Coast Guard plate and Geronimo sez: 'it still not funny when little skeg hits big stump at 45-50 mph and 'ya hang'n on big tiller stick instead of safe round wheel' ???...Ugh !!!

• View Reports by Admiral Rabbit
abeastandasavage Profile Photo
Posted July 01, 2012 at 6:00pm
50hp?

i agree with the admiral, but, thats why they put throttles on outboards!!! if you think u are going to fast and its not safe and are uncomfortable with the speed, just slack off the throttle, problem solved!!! i would rather have a little too much power, than be underpowered!! its much better to be able to run at three quarter throttle, than wide open. motor will last longer and burn less gas!! my common opinion??? some people mite think, its an uncommon opinion???

• View Reports by abeastandasavage

New User? Register
Password? Forgot
Inactive? Activate


Reports / Forum
PAC bank slam number 6ish?  This report contains photos  
May 13 at 1:52 pm | 3388 Views | 33 Comments
2 limit of cats  This report contains photos  
May 12 at 4:12 pm | 3118 Views | 8 Comments
First noodling trip of the year  This report contains photos  
May 14 at 10:20 am | 2186 Views | 1 Comments
how to find oyster reefs 
May 12 at 6:39 pm | 2100 Views | 5 Comments
Breton Sound Bullred Fishkill.  This report contains photos   This report contains a video
Yesterday at 12:12 pm | 2002 Views | 8 Comments
Father-Daughter team none stop action out of Shell Beach.  This report contains photos  
May 15 at 10:03 pm | 1922 Views | 2 Comments
Trestles 5/15/13  This report contains photos  
May 16 at 8:32 pm | 1720 Views | 6 Comments
Sick Trout Action! 5-14-13  This report contains photos  
May 14 at 10:10 pm | 1537 Views | 1 Comments
Easy Breezy in May  This report contains photos   This report contains a video
May 13 at 9:02 pm | 1354 Views | 0 Comments
Geauxpass Scam  This report contains photos  
May 13 at 7:48 pm | 1311 Views | 8 Comments
Capt. Bob's Leeville Report  This report contains photos  
May 13 at 6:48 pm | 1265 Views | 1 Comments
Trestle Report 
May 16 at 12:58 am | 1234 Views | 2 Comments
Best Area to Learn for Beginner 
May 16 at 2:02 pm | 1142 Views | 18 Comments
Aj'S Thick around rig  This report contains photos  
May 14 at 7:59 am | 1127 Views | 0 Comments
lake Pontchartrain 
May 15 at 10:34 pm | 1099 Views | 8 Comments
Tuna time!  This report contains photos  
May 16 at 3:18 pm | 1046 Views | 3 Comments
What's the spillway looking like? 
May 15 at 7:47 pm | 980 Views | 6 Comments
PAC monster slam!!!!  This report contains photos  
Yesterday at 2:06 pm | 960 Views | 2 Comments
Venice vs Grand Isle  This report contains photos  
Yesterday at 11:37 am | 824 Views | 3 Comments
SPECK-tacular!!! 5-15-13  This report contains photos  
May 15 at 5:22 pm | 808 Views | 0 Comments
Post | Reports | Forum
PAC bank slam number 6ish?  This report contains photos  
May 13 at 1:52 pm | 3388 Views | 33 Comments
SCARY!!  This report contains photos  
May 16 at 3:59 pm | 743 Views | 22 Comments
Best Area to Learn for Beginner 
May 16 at 2:02 pm | 1142 Views | 18 Comments
Need tips on best kayak spots 
May 14 at 11:12 pm | 594 Views | 9 Comments
2 limit of cats  This report contains photos  
May 12 at 4:12 pm | 3118 Views | 8 Comments
Geauxpass Scam  This report contains photos  
May 13 at 7:48 pm | 1311 Views | 8 Comments
Pete's Landing 
May 15 at 7:51 am | 443 Views | 8 Comments
lake Pontchartrain 
May 15 at 10:34 pm | 1099 Views | 8 Comments
How to get my burn permit? 
May 16 at 10:04 pm | 223 Views | 8 Comments
Ski fish  This report contains photos  
Yesterday at 11:47 am | 706 Views | 8 Comments
Breton Sound Bullred Fishkill.  This report contains photos   This report contains a video
Yesterday at 12:12 pm | 2002 Views | 8 Comments
CCA REEF 
May 16 at 9:51 am | 326 Views | 7 Comments
Duck blinds on public land 
May 13 at 1:03 am | 779 Views | 6 Comments
New to Louisiana 
May 13 at 8:07 pm | 370 Views | 6 Comments
What's the spillway looking like? 
May 15 at 7:47 pm | 980 Views | 6 Comments
Trestles 5/15/13  This report contains photos  
May 16 at 8:32 pm | 1720 Views | 6 Comments
how to find oyster reefs 
May 12 at 6:39 pm | 2100 Views | 5 Comments
2 stroke or 4 
May 15 at 2:07 pm | 302 Views | 4 Comments
Hopedale 
May 15 at 9:23 am | 469 Views | 4 Comments
'She Met Her Waterloo' 
May 15 at 11:06 am | 260 Views | 4 Comments
Post | Reports | Forum
REEL LIFE FISHING  This report contains photos  
6 hours ago | 85 Views | 0 Comments
Fourchon Beach 
7 hours ago | 67 Views | 0 Comments
Catfish 
8 hours ago | 66 Views | 0 Comments
Beautiful Trout in the Breton Sound  This report contains photos  
9 hours ago | 159 Views | 0 Comments
Let's do it again!  This report contains photos  
10 hours ago | 108 Views | 0 Comments
hwy 11  This report contains photos  
11 hours ago | 173 Views | 0 Comments
Dularge 5-18-13 
11 hours ago | 178 Views | 1 Comments
Sorrel 5/18 
12 hours ago | 111 Views | 4 Comments
Trout Slam 5-18-13  This report contains photos  
12 hours ago | 281 Views | 0 Comments
TEACH ME AKA HELP 
14 hours ago | 97 Views | 1 Comments
5/18 
16 hours ago | 221 Views | 0 Comments
Fouchon 5/18  This report contains photos  
17 hours ago | 471 Views | 1 Comments
Automotive Service Association Fishing Rodeo  This report contains a video
17 hours ago | 41 Views | 0 Comments
trolling motor on a budget  This report contains photos  
19 hours ago | 478 Views | 4 Comments
Trip to Mechant/Sister Lake 
19 hours ago | 66 Views | 0 Comments
Thank God for what we have. 
20 hours ago | 255 Views | 0 Comments
Benelli Question 
23 hours ago | 66 Views | 0 Comments
Check out this video!  This report contains a video
Yesterday at 5:12 am | 159 Views | 1 Comments
Cypremort Point heating up  This report contains photos  
Yesterday at 2:20 am | 192 Views | 0 Comments
Bashing the trout 5-17-13  This report contains photos  
Yesterday at 9:12 pm | 381 Views | 1 Comments
Post | Reports | Forum





featured merchant

Forrest Metal Works
Forrest Metal Works Metal Buildings, Metal Roofs (including standing seam). Commercial & Residental Camper Covers, Boat Covers, Sheds. Standard models or Custom desings.